|
By
Donna L. Wagner
In
the fall of 1997, The National Council on the Aging conmissioned
a study to examine the factors that influence the use of older
workers by U.S. employers. The study, conducted by Towson
University, included a telephone survey of 240 employers regarding
their experience with and attitudes toward older workers as
well as the extent to which they were planning for an increase
in older workers in the future. The findings indicate that,
for the most part, employers in this country hold positive
attitudes toward older workerstoward older workers and have
positive experiences with those older workers in their workforce.
However, the findings also show that most employers are not
planning on an increase in older workers in the future, nor
are they including older workers in their strategic plans.
Since
the passage of Social Security laws and until recently, we
have seen an increase in the percentages of older people who
retire at age 65 or earlier and a decrease in the percentage
of older people employed in the workplace. This downward trend
in employment for older people has generally been attributed
to the availability of both Social Security and private pension
benefits: more older people have had the resources to retire.
However,
Burkhauser and Quinn suggest that retirement and work patterns
for older people are influenced by more complex forces than
merely access to retirement benefits. Their analysis points
to an unanticipated increase in labor participation rates
of older people between 1993 and 1996---a period of strong
economic growth in the nation. Their interpretation of the
underlying factors associated with this increase counters
two widely held misconceptions regarding older workers: 1)
that older people are not interested in working; and 2) that
employers aren't interested in the older worker. In fact,
a 1993 Commonwealth Fund study found that more than five million
older Americans were ready, willing, and able to work but
could not locate an appropriate position. And, as the recent
increases in labor-force participation demonstrate, when the
economy grows and employees are needed, older workers are
included in the hiring mix.
There
are still serious age discrimination problems in the country,
and not all employers have enthusiasm for older workers. But
a strong economy can be as important as positive agewise attitudes
in fostering new opportunities for older workers. And, according
to other researchers, the future looks rosy for the older
adult interested in new career opportunities or part-time
work. Alan Peynolds, Director of Economic Research at the
Hudson Institute, suggests that in the future, the American
economy will be influenced more by the scarcity of workers
than a lack of jobs. This means that the very large group
of older people may well become a valuable asset for the economy
rather than a "drain" on Social Security in the
future.
How do
employers view older workers today? Do employers realize that
they may need older workers in the future? And what barriers
do employers perceive in using older workers? These are a
few of the questions we asked 240 representatives of employers
throughout the U.S.
As
mentioned earlier, employers reported very positive attitudes
and beliefs about older workers. Most respondents reported
that they believed older workers were reliable, thorough,
conscientious, and dependable. In general, the employers embraced
the key benefits often touted about older workers---they have
fewer on-the-job accidents, miss less time than younger workers,
and are very conscientious and careful in carrying out their
assignments. About one-fourth of the respondents were concerned
about two things---whether the older person's skills are out-of-date
and whether older workers are willing to take on demanding
or difficult tasks.
One informant
who runs a company in the health sector offered another observation
about older workers: "They come to the workplace without
all the baggage that we often see with younger workers,"
she reported. In her experience, the older workers were more
likely to be unfettered by chaotic personal lives, sick children,
and other distractions and spent their time at work "on
task."
Barriers
to Hiring Older People
When asked
about the barriers to using older workers, the most often
cited barrier for these employers (61 percent of the sample)
was finding the older workers. In fact, several of the respondents
asked the interviewers about possible sources and programs
that would help them locate older workers. The three employment
sectors most likely to report difficulties locating older
workers were business services, health, and retail. The skill
levels of older workers were considered to be a barrier by
half of the respondents.
Half of
the respondents believed that they will see an increase in
the number of older workers in their workforce within the
next five years. But only I I percent reported that their
company had developed a strategic plan for increases in older
workers; an- other 17 percent reported that older workers
had been identified as an issue that needed to be addressed
in their planning for the future.
Despite
the fact that older workers are likely to be needed in the
future to maintain econorrlic growth, the majority of the
companies (73 percent) had no plan in place to effectively
incorporate increasing numbers of older workers into their
workforce in the years ahead. There are, of course, companies
that have taken a proactive approach to older workers. McDonald's
has successfully integrated older people into its workforce
and has publicly advertised the value they place on these
older workers. In fact, one respondent felt personally reassured
by these McDonald's ads. He reported that they made him feel
more optimistic about his own options when he retires and
pursues a new career path. And, the ads influenced his own
hiring practices and made him more aware of the untapped resources
within the older population that could benefit his current
employer.
The
survey findings suggest that many employers in the United
States today expect to see an increase in older workers in
their workforce, and the employers in general hold positive
attitudes and beliefs about older workers. However, advocates
for older workers need to address two concerns the employers
expressed: finding older workers and the skill level of older
workers. (Among responding employers, older workers were most
often employed in service-sectorjobs.) If it were easier for
employers to find older workers, and if they could be convinced
that older workers have up-to-date skills or that they can
easily learn new skills, other sectors might be more likely
to hire older workers as well.
*Donna L. Wagner, Ph.D., is director of gerontology
at Towson University in Towson, Maryland. Before joining the
faculty at Towson, Dr. Wagner was vice president for research
and development at NCOA (e-mail address: dwagner@saber.towson.edu).
|